In my previous post I ended with the binutils test suite not being happy after steering off the guide and making some changes to which components were installed. I decided to start again but cut back on the changes and see just how much I could omit from installing to get to the point of completing chapter 8. Ideally, I would like to shed everything that’s only a build dependency. It was doable but the sticking point was Python which is needed by Meson / ninja in order to build systemd and though you build Python earlier in chapter 7, at that stage it is built without the ctypes module as it requires libffi and the ctypes module is needed by Meson.
I thought I’d cheat by using pkgsrc to satisfy the build dependencies but the infrastructure for detecting termcap support is unable to detect support via ncursesw which LFS uses. Opting to prefer satisfying all dependencies from pkgsrc which is now the default setting for pkgsrc on Linux created a new problem that the components you compile manually outside of pkgsrc which call pkg-config would link to the pkgsrc versions of dependencies. To side step this issue I moved the pkg-config binary from pkgsrc out of the way where upon I hit an issue with linking systemd. After a night’s sleep I found that ninja in pkgsrc is patched to not adjust the rpath in binaries and this is need for systemd’s binaries because the libraries they depend on are tucked away in a subdirectory.
Upon completing chapter 8, I went back and started afresh once more, this time with the intent to make changes and substitutions once again. I installed bash as
/bin/bash but did not create a link to
/bin/sh and was surprised to find most things were happy with that, the autoconfed infrastructure could cope, until I reached binutils in chapter 8 where it called
/bin/sh explicitly in tests. At this point I installed mksh and pointed
/bin/sh to it. This revealed various failures from scripts and tests on other packages which were built after binutils in chapter 8, most significantly by GCC’s build infrastructure. Setting the
CONIFG_SHELL variable to
/bin/bash when envoking
configure ensured that bash was called instead of
sh during the build and when invoking the test stage, as the
SHELL variable inherits this setting down the line and things move on smoothly. I need to look at getting binutils handle the override as well, rather than hardcoding
All build dependencies were installed in a separate prefix so that they could be removed after the build. m4, make, bison, Perl, Python, gawk, pkg-config (built with pc location set to /usr/lib/pkgconfig), autoconf, automake, libffi, check, expect, flex, TCL were installed in this location.
Python’s build infrastructure assumes system provides libffi and if the system doesn’t, it struggles with linking. There’s a bug report to teach the build to make use of the information from pkg-config for libffi but the proposed patch in my case did not work as the location under the new prefix where libraries are installed were not in the search path for the dynamic linker. Since I was installing Python in the same prefix as libffi was already installed in, I adjusted the rpath by setting
Besides the bash to mksh swap for /bin/sh, I replaced gawk with nawk once more, there was no fallout though I did also install gawk under the new prefix as glibc requires it. tar was swapped with bsdtar from libarchive, Man-DB for mandoc.
I skipped on texinfo as it has a Perl runtime dependency and I don’t want to include Perl in the base OS. Groff was out as it had a texinfo dependency. I omitted libelf as I thought it was only used by tc from IPRoute2 which is for setting QoS policies, turns out it’s a build dependency for the kernel so that went back in.
With everything in place, I managed to build a kernel which for some reason couldn’t go multiuser because it couldn’t find init or sh! Comparing the config with my image from round #1 showed lots of differences which was baffling as I thought I’d only made the changes which the LFS guide suggests. Starting with a new config resolved the issue. I can only suspect that I must’ve pressed space bar by accident when navigating the kernel config menus which switched a bunch of stuff off. 🙁
I now have an OS image which appears to work. For the next round to put it to the test, I am going to try and use it to build a new distro. I will need to address the binutils build infrastructure issue so that I can point it to bash, otherwise I suspect I will run into the issues again when running the test suite (see previous post). I would also like to try and swap binutils out for elftoolchain. I have also been thinking about subsequent OS upgrades and using mtree for that.